🌅 Islamorada’s Best Kept Secret: Lorelei Restaurant and Cabana Bar – A Must-Stop for the Discerning Palate

If your current Florida Keys escape itinerary does not feature Lorelei Restaurant and Cabana Bar in Islamorada, consider this your official notification: You are missing out on an experience that defines the quintessential South Florida dining excursion.
Lorelei has definitively claimed its spot as one of our absolute favorite stops in our Key West series. This is an institution for those who appreciate a blend of sophisticated casual and breathtaking waterfront views.
Our recent visit confirmed Lorelei is a masterclass in elevating classic Keys fare.
We began with the superb Bacon Wrapped Shrimp—lightly fried, served with a sweet Thai chili sauce. This juxtaposition of savory and sweet was an intelligent opening act.
For our main course, we shared the legendary LORELEI’s Famous Fish, a perfectly blackened grouper sandwich on a fresh brioche bun. It’s an honest, elevated take on a seaside classic.
Our libations were equally noteworthy. Doris chose the vibrant, perfectly balanced Mango Margarita, and I enjoyed the classic Rum Runner, executed with depth and complexity.
You simply cannot conclude your visit without indulging in their pièce de résistance: Lorelei’s World Famous “Frozen” Key Lime Pie. This frozen iteration delivers a spectacular balance of bracingly tart lime and creamy sweetness. It is, quite frankly, non-negotiable.
Lorelei offers an immersive, picturesque experience that is begging to be documented.

Here is your essential directive:
Visit: Go immediately! This view, this food, and this atmosphere are worth the drive.
Document: Capture your Mango Margarita, the Blackened Grouper, the stunning backdrop, and that World Famous Key Lime Pie.
Share the Wealth: Tag your photos and videos with @SoFloDining to share your moments with fellow discerning foodies.
A Nudge to the Staff: When you arrive, let them know you saw this review on SoFloDining!
Do not delay your visit. Go. Indulge. And tell them we sent you.

📝 Essential Details