7 Mile Grill – Legendary Key Lime Pie & Classic Keys Seafood in Marathon (A SoFloDining Revisit)

Alright, food fanatics, buckle up! Your favorite food-obsessed duo, Doris and yours truly, have just returned from a pilgrimage to a Keys institution – the legendary 7 Mile Grill at 1240 Overseas Hwy in Marathon! And let me tell you, folks, this place still delivers that classic, sun-kissed Keys vibe that keeps us coming back for more. Serving fresh seafood and good times since 1954, this cozy, no-frills, dockside gem, nestled next to a marina, is truly timeless.

Our history with 7 Mile Grill started five years ago, converting me—a non-fish-eater—into a true believer with their Blackened Grouper and Blackened Mahi Mahi sandwiches that practically melted in our mouths.

This time around, we started with an order of their iconic Conch Fritters. And let me tell you, these weren’t just fritters; they were works of art. Deep golden brown on the outside, unbelievably soft and flavorful on the inside. Each bite was a symphony of textures and tastes, and you could practically taste the freshness of every ingredient. This is the kind of attention to detail that separates the good from the GREAT.

We followed that up with a simple, yet satisfying, basket of fried shrimp. Perfection, people! Perfectly golden-brown, plump, and juicy shrimp, which were served with crispy, fresh-cut fries. And to wash it all down? Two ice-cold, gigantic root beers. Pure bliss.

Now, let’s talk about the legendary, made-in-house Key Lime Pie! This isn’t overly sweet or overly tart; it’s perfectly balanced with a graham cracker crust that sang with every bite. We were so stuffed from our recent feast that we sadly couldn’t indulge this time, but Doris has already decreed we start with it first on our next visit! Believe me, you don’t want to miss it.

The real magic of 7 Mile Grill doesn’t end with the food. They offer jet ski rentals, a “hook and cook” option, and just a stone’s throw away, you’ll find Shiver Me Timbers, their phenomenal ice cream shop (open 2 PM – 10 PM daily) for a perfect cool-down. 7 Mile Grill is still a MUST-STOP and has truly earned its spot in my top five must-visit locations when cruising through the Keys.

The ultimate FOMO moment comes from delaying your visit and missing out on the legendary, perfectly balanced Key Lime Pie and those unbelievably soft Conch Fritters, which define the decades-long classic Keys charm.

Essential Details