Jimmy Johnson’s Big Chill: Secure Your Waterside Table for the Quintessential Upper Keys Experience

When the Florida Keys beckon and the search for authentic Island Vibe leaves you overwhelmed, trust the locals: Jimmy Johnson’s Big Chill is the unequivocal “must-visit.” The moment you enter, you are instantly engulfed by the breezy, unmistakable aroma of coastal cuisine and saltwater air. This is where impeccable service meets unexpected culinary abundance, all set against a stunning bay view.

The atmosphere is one of vibrant, casual celebration, yet every detail—from the expansive, multi-level dining options to the warm, attentive service (thank you, Alvaro)—speaks of sophisticated island hospitality. This spot is clearly an Upper Keys institution, frequently hosting celebrations and major parties within its entertainment complex.

The flavors are extraordinary. Start your journey with the legendary Shrimp Bisque Fries, an Idaho potato fries delight topped with house-made Shrimp Bisque, Applewood smoked bacon, and scallions that deliver an incredible, robust, and utterly “OMG-level” flavor far beyond expectation. For the main course, entrées like the Dolphin Reuben (Local Mahi with 1000 Island, Tropical Mango Slaw, and melted Swiss on rye) and the Blackened Local Grouper Sandwich (with roasted red pepper mayo) are fresh, tender, and consistently delightful. Even the custom cocktails—like the RX (with Bacardi, Havana Club, Coconut, and Pineapple) and the refreshing Paloma—are highly recommended.

Big Chill offers experiences few other Keys spots dare to attempt. On your next visit, you must not miss the waterside seating next to the docks for the full show of boats coming in, the live entertainment, and the dedicated, full-service bar.

The ultimate FOMO moment comes with the service, as your server expertly guides you through the menu, often sharing fascinating history about the local area and the venue itself. Even the simple act of ordering a second round cocktail as a “liquid dessert” is encouraged.

This restaurant’s high local and visitor demand, particularly for its beautiful waterfront views and ample entertainment, means that availability, especially for the prime tables, is quickly consumed. Make reservations in advance and arrive early to guarantee your spot for this truly special occasion location.