Papa Joe’s in Islamorada | A Waterfront Escape

Alright, foodies! Doris and I just had an experience that’s practically begging to be shouted from the rooftops. We ventured down to the Florida Keys, and let me tell you, we weren’t just looking for a meal, we were looking for an escape. And folks, we found it at Papa Joe’s Waterfront in Islamorada. Located right on the water at 79786 Overseas Highway, this gem offers the intoxicating vibe of sun shimmering, salty breezes, and the promise of pure, unadulterated deliciousness. This isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a slice of island paradise that delivers on every level.

The ambiance is just as fantastic as the food. We decided to park ourselves at the iconic upstairs Tiki Bar, perched above the action, overlooking the cornhole games and soaking in the water views. The energy is infectious, and the laid-back Key’s charm is palpable.

First things first: the libations! Doris, the tropical queen, went straight for the Frozen Piña Colada. I opted for the Frozen Rum Runner. Both were absolute perfection—creamy, fruity, and perfectly balanced. While they offer a “floater” (extra rum), the drinks were so well-crafted, they were perfect as is! This is the kind of place where you can completely unwind and forget about the world.

The real star of the show? The food, of course! We’d heard whispers, legends even, about their Wagyu Hot Dog, and let me tell you, the hype is real. This isn’t your average ballpark frank! It’s a culinary masterpiece. We are serious about our hot dogs, and this one, topped with sweet and savory caramelized onions, rich beer cheese sauce, and crunchy bacon bits, made it into the top three of my entire life!

The menu boasts something for everyone, and we can’t wait to go back and explore more of their offerings. We’re already plotting our return to try those tantalizing Coconut Shrimp Tacos we saw heading out to other tables.

Overall, our dining experience at Papa Joe’s Waterfront was exceptional. It’s a true gem in Islamorada, and a must-visit for anyone looking for delicious food, refreshing drinks, and a slice of paradise.

The ultimate FOMO moment comes from delaying your visit and missing out on the legendary Wagyu Hot Dog and the pure bliss of enjoying a Frozen Rum Runner from the iconic Tiki Bar, which define the perfect Keys escape.

Essential Details