Sloppy Joe’s on the Beach: Where R&R Meets Treasure Island’s Hidden Culinary Gem

You arrive seeking rest, but the universe has other plans. Tucked within the elegant Bilmar Beach Resort, the authentic sound of live, daily music will draw you in from your leisurely beachside stroll. This is Sloppy Joe’s: the only beachfront destination that effortlessly blends a lively, sophisticated vibe with a menu that demands repeat visits.

This isn’t typical resort fare; it’s an elevated beach experience confirmed by its loyal clientele—including those who confess to having broken their own rule by dining here three nights in a row. The service is nothing short of impeccable, with a staff (like Janique and Taylor) who are both professional and genuinely welcoming, guiding you through every curated detail.

The cocktails are essential. Indulge in the Orange Blossom (featuring Grey Goose and St. Germain) or the original Rum Runner, made with authentic Key West local rum. The cuisine maintains this high standard, from perfectly seasoned Peel-and-Eat Shrimp and the comforting warmth of the Lobster Bisque to the incredible Sirloin Wedge that our guests rave about.

The true highlights—the dishes you must experience—are the rich and savory Lobster Macaroni and Cheese and the legendary Key Lime Pie, hailed as having a flavor worthy of Key West’s best.

With live music every single day and the most sought-after indoor and outdoor seating on the island, the best tables are quickly claimed. This is more than a restaurant; it’s the Whole Experience, the cultural heartbeat of Treasure Island, and the destination everyone will be talking about.

Don’t let the opportunity for discovery pass you by. If you only visit once, you’re missing the true measure of its quality. Secure your spot now and start your own multi-night tradition.